Survivorship: The Next Big Thing
When cancer patients transition from active treatment to survivorship, many find that they are at a loss of how to manage ongoing physical and emotional challenges. Providers hope that increased resources and comprehensive survivorship programming will help these survivors thrive.
Christy Stickney was 42 years old, newly married, and a busy mom to five kids when she was diagnosed with breast cancer in 2010. Determined to fight the disease, Christy says, she faced the challenge head-on. “After my diagnosis it was game on,” she says. “There was no way that cancer would beat me.”
Christy underwent a double mastectomy, breast reconstruction, and chemotherapy. She experienced side effects that included hair loss, fatigue, and “chemo brain,” but she kept fighting—right up until the point she was supposed to be on the road to recovery. It was after her treatment was complete, when she was supposed to move on with her life, that Christy found herself in a deep depression, not sure how to move forward.
“Here I was, five months out of chemo, my main surgeries behind me, and all I could think about was going to sleep and never waking up,” she says. Christy had come through the challenges of diagnosis and treatment only to find that it was recovery—physical and emotional—that seemed the biggest hurdle yet. “During my cancer battle, I never considered giving up,” she says. “I was laser-focused on doing whatever was needed to beat this monster. So why now was I in this dark place, ready to end it all?”
It was the transition from active treatment to recovery that presented a chasm Christy didn’t know how to bridge: “My prognosis was good, yet I felt like the life preserver I had been using for the past year and a half had been taken away. I was told to swim to shore, yet I had no arms. I should be able to do this, yet I was drowning. My surgical team and oncologist were some of the best in our area, yet here I was, so completely ill-prepared for the next part of my journey—recovery.”
The Road through Recovery Is Not Always Easy
Unfortunately, Christy’s post-treatment survivorship experience is not unique. Many cancer patients push through treatment, keeping their eye on the prize, only to realize that the end of active treatment can present its own set of physical and emotional challenges that require an entirely different approach and a new set of tools.
Often, says Amy Jacobson, RN, NP-BC, a nurse practitioner at the UCLA-LiveSTRONG Survivorship Center of Excellence, “survivors face the sense of not knowing where to go from here—here being the end of treatment. During treatment it’s clear what the plan is, but once active treatment ends, many survivors feel unsure about what tests they need, who is managing their care, and who they should go to if problems arise.”
Some of the most common issues patients face at this juncture include fear of recurrence, ongoing physical side effects from treatment, emotional distress, ongoing financial and insurance issues, and the lack of a comprehensive long-term care plan. Facing these challenges at a time when family and friends might assume that the most difficult stage of the journey has been completed can leave survivors feeling misunderstood and guilty for continuing to struggle at a time when they are expected to thrive.
Fran Zandstra, BSN, MBA, RN, executive director of the Cancer Survivorship Program at MD Anderson Cancer Center, says that a patient of hers once described the challenge of transitioning from active treatment to recovery this way: “The second-worst day of my life is when they told me, ‘You don’t have to come back,’ because during treatment, when you’re getting medicine, there’s something keeping the cancer away; but when treatment is over, everyone thinks, She’ll be just like she was, but that’s just not the way it is.”
Transforming the Survivorship Care Model
According to a recent review of survivorship statistics, the number of patients facing issues related to the transition from active treatment to long-term survivorship is growing: “The number of cancer survivors in the US has increased from 3 million in 1971, when the National Cancer Act was enacted, to over 12 million today. Over 70 percent of children affected by cancer survive more than 10 years, and most are cured. Most cancer survivors are adults, with two-thirds of them 65 years of age or older and two-thirds alive at five years.” With this growing population of survivors, managing ongoing care and side effects is becoming a major concern among providers.
Patricia A. Ganz, MD, professor at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) Schools of Medicine and Public Health and a researcher at UCLA’s Jonsson Comprehensive Cancer Center, says that the need for addressing survivorship care was officially presented to the oncology community in a 2005 Institute of Medicine (IOM) report titled From Cancer Patient to Cancer Survivor: Lost in Transition. The report described the lack of best practices and guidelines for survivors’ ongoing care and recommended the use of survivorship care plans, which would summarize the history of a patient’s cancer care and be passed along to any providers who care for the patient after he or she completes active treatment.
Dr. Ganz says that it was in response to the IOM report that the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) and the European Society for Medical Oncology (ESMO), created a consensus statement on quality cancer care, released in 2006, which included a goal for “survivorship care planning.” In addition, many cancer centers heeded the call for increased survivorship resources, developing survivorship programs and implementing the use of survivorship care plans to help patients and providers navigate recovery (see sidebar “Make a Plan”).
Today, six years after the ASCO-ESMO statement, a range of comprehensive survivorship program models that seek to bridge the gap between active treatment and long-term recovery are in evidence across the country. Zandstra says that the survivorship program she oversees covers four distinct areas to respond to the various challenges that patients face during the transition from active treatment to recovery. “At MD Anderson we’re addressing surveillance for the disease, late effects of treatment, risk reduction and screening for second cancers, and psychosocial issues. Our survivorship program is constructed around those four domains.” Providers help patients access resources across the four domains, Zandstra says, coordinating medical and complementary therapies to “move from the illness focus to the wellness focus, asking always, ‘How do we optimize wellness?”
At the UCLA-LiveSTRONG Survivorship Center of Excellence, Amy Jacobson says, programming is built around the survivorship care plan. “The cornerstone of the program is the Treatment Summary and Survivorship Care Plan, which is generated from an initial visit—during which a patient sees a psychologist or social worker, a medical oncologist, and a nurse practitioner—and is provided to the patient as well as their medical team; it outlines their diagnosis and treatment and provides recommendations for their care moving forward.”
The MD Anderson and UCLA survivorship programs serve as excellent examples of the good that has come from the increasing recognition of need among survivors, and there has been improvement in addressing the challenge, Dr. Ganz says. “There has been modest progress, mostly at major cancer centers and in some community cancer centers,” she says, “and the American College of Surgeons cancer program accreditation process has now adopted this as a standard, which should result in greater uptake.” Still, she says, we have work to do to ensure that patients are provided with the care they need after treatment ends. “It takes a long time to disseminate quality-of-care activities such as this, and many barriers are raised to do this.”
For patients who have not been treated at a major cancer center or community cancer center that has implemented components of a survivorship program, Zandstra recommends proactive self-assessment and seeking out services in their own communities. Most important, she says, is to communicate regularly with providers about any questions or issues that arise. “After treatment patients should make a list of questions they may have about what comes next,” she says, “and they should continue to communicate with their care team about any symptoms.” Sometimes just talking about the issues that arise—and hearing that they are a normal part of the recovery process—can be helpful. “Your healthcare team really wants you to be your own advocate,” Zandstra says. “Saying it out loud is not going to make you have cancer, and your team really needs to know what’s going on.”
Striving for More Positive Stories of Survivorship
The important work being done at cancer centers around the country to provide survivorship programming and to increase awareness of the issue is making a difference in the lives of survivors—as are patients like Christy Stickney, who by sharing their stories are offering hope to others navigating this challenging phase of the cancer journey.
Though Christy did not have access to an established survivorship program, she did ultimately find support through her recovery by seeking counseling, working with a naturopath to manage the effects of treatment-induced menopause, getting support from her church, and turning to family and friends.
Now Christy hopes that by sharing her experience and describing the difficult time she endured, she can help bring awareness of the challenge of this phase of survivorship so that other survivors avoid the hardship she faced. “My daughter, who is eight, was studying her spelling recently and asked me the meaning of the word despair,” Christy says. “I told her it means to give up, to lose hope. She walked over to me and gave me a big hug. She told me she was glad that never happened to me. Someday I will tell her, but in the meantime my goal, my passion, is to bring awareness to this issue—to hopefully help at least one person not end up where I did.”
More Tips for Survivors Transitioning to Recovery
From Fran Zandstra, BSN, MBA, RN, executive director of the Cancer Survivorship Program at MD Anderson Cancer Center
- If possible, while still in active treatment, ask, “What happens next?”
- At the end of treatment, ask for a survivorship care plan or summary of care so that you have a pathway that says what your life is going to look like moving forward.
- Once you’ve completed treatment, reestablish your healthcare team at home and ask questions to understand the role of each provider moving forward: What is my oncologist going to do? My primary care doctor?
- Make sure you have access to your records so that you have a permanent reference for your treatment history.
- Set manageable goals to help you make steady progress forward. Goals can be as simple as Today I’m going to walk around the block.
Make a Plan
So, you’re finishing up treatment and you’re wondering what’s next. Who will oversee your treatment? When should you schedule follow-up appointments? Is counseling a good idea? What kind of long-term side effects should you look out for? Many of these questions can be adressed through a survivorship care plan—a document that you can create together with your healthcare team, which will outline your diagnosis and treatment history and help guide future medical care.
Survivorship care plans have become increasingly popular, as cancer treatment centers strive to support survivors through recovery. In the wake of the 2005 IOM report outlining the need for more-standardized and comprehensive survivorship care, several organizations came together to promote the use of survivorship care plans among patients and providers. The result of the initiative—a partnership of the National Coalition for Cancer Survivorship, the UCLA Cancer Survivorship Center, the Oncology Nursing Society, WellPoint, and Genentech—was Journey Forward, which encourages patients and physicians to work together to plan for ongoing care and support.
Jennifer Hausman, MPH, public health program director at WellPoint, says, “Survivorship care plans, completed by the survivor’s oncology team, give clear steps for care after active treatment.” Hausman says that the plans begin with a treatment summary and offer guidelines for monitoring future care, including important information about monitoring for possible secondary cancers and late- or long-term effects of cancer treatment: “A care plan relieves a survivor of having to recall all the details of treatment and ensures all future healthcare providers are working as a team for the survivor’s care.”
There are a variety of survivorship care plan templates available to patients and providers, but Hausman says what’s most important is that the patient and his or her entire care team have a copy of the completed document so that healthcare can be coordinated and monitored after treatment ends. She adds that these are the important components of a plan:
- Patient diagnosis and concise treatment summary
- Best schedule for follow-up tests
- Information on late- and long-term effects of cancer treatment
- Psychosocial assessment and recommended interventions
- List of symptoms to watch for
- List of support resources
For more information about survivorship care planning, visit journeyforward.org.
. Valdivieso M, Kujawa AM, Jones T, Baker LH. Cancer survivors in the United States: a review of the literature and a call to action. International Journal of Medical Sciences. 2012;9(2):163-73.